Petrie

Glassy Bay Outfitters, based out of Elliot Lake, Ontario, generally earns strong positive reviews from guests who have taken fly-in fishing trips to the Bark Lake chain and surrounding remote lakes. The majority of reviewers describe their experiences in enthusiastic terms, highlighting the spectacular scenery during the floatplane flights, the remoteness and solitude of the camps, and the quality of walleye and northern pike fishing. Staff communication and professionalism — particularly around scheduling and flights — are mentioned positively, and the overall sense of escaping into genuine wilderness is a recurring theme.

Guests consistently praise the walleye fishing, with one group reporting catch-and-release numbers of 250 keeper-sized walleye among five anglers over a trip. The remoteness of the lakes, the absence of other anglers, and the natural surroundings are frequently highlighted as major draws. However, there is at least one notable complaint worth considering: a repeat customer reported being placed at a different lake than requested after three years of loyal visits, encountering a significant drop in fishing quality, poor cabin conditions, and a bug problem. Most critically, that reviewer states they were not informed by the outfitter that the area had been heavily netted by local Indigenous fishers the prior spring, which the reviewer felt was information they were owed before the trip. This suggests that communication around lake conditions and cabin assignments may not always be consistent, and guests should confirm specific cabin and lake requests clearly in advance.

Glassy Bay Outfitters appears best suited for small groups of experienced or semi-experienced anglers — particularly those targeting walleye — who are comfortable with rustic, self-guided wilderness camp conditions and are primarily seeking solitude and remote access rather than guided service or amenities. It may also appeal to first-time fly-in guests looking for a genuine off-the-grid experience near Elliot Lake. Those with specific lake or cabin preferences, or who are sensitive to variability in fishing conditions, should communicate those expectations directly with the outfitter before booking.